Estefania's blog

December 12th, 2010

Bibliography and Weblography

Posted by esefer in SECOND PAPER
  • BIBLIOGRAPHY

–          Bregazzi, Josephine (1999). Shakespeare y el teatro renacentista inglés. Madrid: Alianza Editorial, S.A. 106-109.

–          Hadfield, Andrew and Hammond, Paul (2004). Shakespeare and Reinassance Europe. London: The Arden Shakespeare.

–          Kehler, Dorothea (2001). A midsummer Night’s Dream Critical essays. London: Routledge.

–          Thorne, Alison (2003). Shakespeare’s Romances. New York: Palgrave

–          Wells, Stanley (1990). Shakespeare. A biographical guide. New York: Oxford

  • WEBLOGRAPHY

–          Internet Shakespeare Editions. (2010). As you like it: Introduction. Available from: http://internetshakespeare.uvic.ca/Library/Texts/AYL/intro/GenIntro/default/.  Last accessed: 3 Dec 2010.

Internet Shakespeare Editions. (2010). As you like it (Modern). Available from:  http://internetshakespeare.uvic.ca/Library/Texts/AYL/M/default/ .  Last accessed: 5 Dec 2010.

Internet Shakespeare Editions. (2010). Much Ado About Nothing (Folio 1, 1623). Available from: http://internetshakespeare.uvic.ca/Annex/Texts/Ado/F1/default/ . Last accessed: 9 Dec 2010.

Spark Notes. (2010). Much Ado About Nothing. Themes, Motifs & Symbols. Available from: http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/muchado/themes.html . Last accessed: 10 Dec 2010.

December 12th, 2010

Conclusion

Posted by esefer in SECOND PAPER

Let me not to the marriage of true minds

Admit impediments. Love is not love

Which alters when it alteration finds,

Or bends with the remover to remove.

 

                                                    Sonnet 116.

William Shakespeare

In these three comedies Shakespeare presents two different worlds; the world of reality and the world of fantasy. He presents the reality as the one that is located in the city and the court this is the world of: the injustices, the reason, the law, the men, and it represent the reality of the period. On the other hand we found this one of fantasy in these imaginary lands in the scenarios he creates to be able to set these two worlds. The world of fantasy is that one where the dreams may come true, where the magic and the supernatural exist as in A Midsummer Night’s Dream, the world where the men and women are free, where they can love and be corresponded and where poetry exists as in As You Like It. In the last two pastoral comedies this fantasy world corresponds to the forest. Much Ado About Nothing is closer to reality than to fantasy. This time we do not set the fantasy world in any other place separate from the city, but in elements, situations, idealized conducts which do not belong to reality. He uses the fantasy to intensify that power in the strong vein of reality with which he has dramatized the stories.

To talk about fantasy, as we can see in the three plays they not only have in common that imaginary scenarios Shakespeare creates but also in them the lovers need fantasy as well as the audience needs it to be entertained, this balance between fantasy and reality is the success of the Shakespearean’s work.

To conclude, these comedies take similar approaches, the author uses the distant ‘out there’, the world of fantasy, where everything is possible and the dreams may come true, to tell us the reality, the familiar situations of the time. He does not represent the fantasy as the ideal world but necessary. Life is not only fantasy but fantasy should be a part of our life.

December 11th, 2010

Fantasy and Reality in: Much Ado About Nothing in comparison with A Midsummer Night’s Dream

Posted by esefer in SECOND PAPER

Fantasy and reality are prominent themes in every Shakespearean play, but it is seen in each play in a different way. To talk about fantasy and reality in the comedy Much Ado About Nothing we will look for another reading of the play, where this time, I will situate this literary work in the world of reality with fantasy nuances.

As in A midsummer Night’s Dream in Much Ado About Nothing we find fantasy in the lack of conventions in the scenarios created by the author. While the play A Midsummer Night’s Dream could be located in the fantasy world (which also involves magic) with elements, situations which belong to the world of reality, the play Much Ado About Nothing is a more realistic play that on the other hand I will locate in the world of reality with elements, conducts, situations and characters which belong to the fantasy world. We understand by fantasy anything which apart us from the harsh reality of the Shakespearean period.

Perhaps the title Much Ado About Nothing is given by Shakespeare because most of the situations are representative situations of the time. The mixture of fantasy and reality in some of those conventions of the time are the follows:

 The main themes of the play are: the importance of honor, a daughter’s duty, the death, the love, the deception, and betrayal, therefore as I said before this play is closer to the reality that to the fantasy world. But as a comedy, all those conflicts the reality represents as in A Midsummer Night’s Dream they have to be solved through the fantasy.

The importance of honor in that era was not, as anything, the same for women and for men and this is reflected in Much Ado About Nothing. Hero’s wedding with Claudio is aborted because she is accused of infidelity; she loses her honor, based upon her virginity, in front of her father by having sexual relations before marriage. In Shakespeare’s times this meant the death of the woman and the lost of her social status. ‘Would the Princes lie, and Claudio lie, Who lou’d her so, that speaking of her foulnesse, Wash’d it with teares? Hence from her, let her die’(4.1.1815-1817)  Leonato, after this scandal he orders the death of his daughter. The importance of honor for men differs from the women, being a military question for men. They could defend their honor in a battle, for that reason Beatrice through persuasion, orders Benedict to ‘kill Claudio’ (4.1.1952).

A daughter’s duty in Shakespeare’s period is obedience to her father, In A Midsummer Night’s Dream the duty of Hermia is to marry the man her father Egeus wants for her, in Much Ado About Nothing, Hero’s duty is to obey the decision of her father Leonato as well.

Betrayal and deception are also realistic themes presented in the play.  Don John, the villain of the play, lies about the virginity of Hero betraying Claudio. He represents all those malevolence intentions and the deceptions reality carries.

The play shows us multiple endings due to the complex situations, this helps the play to make it more realistic than fantasy, when the audience comes to believe in the illusions of the theatre, and we go back to the world of reality, there is plenty of conflict. But as in every comedy we trust in a happy ending that is why we need to go through fantasy to make it possible.

Above all these themes, what it moves Much Ado About Nothing as the rest of Shakespeare’s plays is the theme of love. Love at first sight and the corresponded love is possible in the theatre and therefore in the world of fantasy. We find a parallelism with the play A Midsummer Night’s Dream in the two couples: Hermia and Lisander are in love from the beginning of the play, so Hero and Claudio. She falls in love with Claudio when he falls for her, but on the other hand Demetrius and Helena as well as Beatrice and Benedict need from fantasy and Helena in love with Demetrius. In contrast with the magic used in A midsummer Night’s Dream to join Helena and Lisander, in Much Ado About Nothing, we will find that fantasy in those scenes where Claudio, Don Pedro and Leonato will act as ‘cupid’ to try to let Benedick know that Breatice loves him and vice versa, Don Pedro says:

‘I will in the interim, undertake one of Hercules labors,

which is, to bring Signior Benedick 

and the Lady Beatrice into a mountaine of affection,

 th’one with th’other, I would faine have it a match,

and I doubt not but to fashion it,

if you three will but minister such assistance

as I shall give you direction’ (2.1.759-764).

 On the other hand Hero and her servant will do the same with Beatrice. At the end, in both plays they have the freedom to choose the day of their weddings even the day after they meet each other. In the following link we can see this funny moment when Benedick first and then Breatrice are persuaded to believe that their love is corresponded, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AlFkbElh44&feature=fvsr.  Here we can also notice in the min 7.52 where Benedick is repeating the same words Beatrice pronounces, that Benedick is under his own fantasy he has been conjured by the three cupids and this is the same for Beatrice

In conclusion, we find reality and fantasy in both plays but it is showed in different ways, in both we need to see that balance to have a happy ending, the lovers need to share these two worlds.

December 11th, 2010

As You Like It and A Midsummer Night’s Dream (fantasy and reality in two pastoral comedies)

Posted by esefer in SECOND PAPER

 

A Midsummer Night’s Dream and As you like it are considerate as pastoral comedies, both present an idealized view of country life against the life of the court. Therefore these two scenarios will represent the world of fantasy and the world of reality. That world of reality belong to the city and the court, the conflicts will start in this one, while the forest, seen as the fantasy world, where everything may come true, will be the place to solve those problems that reality creates.

To start, in As you like it, the reality is found in this duchy of France and in A Midsummer Night’s Dream this world is found in the city of Athens under Theseus rules. In the court the legitimate duke is exiled by a usurper, Duke Frederick. His rules are based on violence and threats to those he considers his political enemies, including anyone loyal to Duke Senior, his brother. In this way he banishes Rosalind for being his brother’s daughter and the only explanation he gives to her is ‘Thou art thy father’s daughter. That’s enough’ (1.3.519). Celia, her desolate cousin, decides to go with her and they dream about all of that they expect to do and to find in the Forest of Arden. They decide to change their names, Celia will be Aliena and Rosalind will no longer be a woman she will dress as a man being Ganymede.

Before leaving, Rosalind falls in love with Orlando, the younger son of Sir Rowland, after he beats Charles in a wrestling match. Because Orlando has beaten Charles in the match his brother wants to kill him, so his servant Adam warns him ‘this house is but a butchery’ (2.3.731) and they will escape to the Forest of Arden.  

As in A Midsummer Nigh’t Dream, the world of reality corresponds to the city and the court where the conflicts start. As the word says, reality is the image of those, events, issues and problems, that the real life of that period represents. The real world is represented as the, the law, the reason, ‘the butchery’, the men rules, the violence, the serious world, the absurdity and the injustices.

 In both plays the lovers and the exiled too, escape from the anguish reality making their way towards the Forest of Arden, an imaginary wood seen as a place of harmony, idealized family relationships, poetic imagination and freedom as the Duke Senior says:

‘Now, my co-mates and brothers in exile,

Hath not old custom made this life more sweet

Than that of painted pomp? Are not these woods

More free from peril than the envious court?

Here feel we not the penalty of Adam,

The seasons’ difference’ (2.1.207-212)

In this place where ‘there is no clock’ (3.2.1493) the problems will be solved. As in A Midsummer Night’s Dream, although there are different motifs to run to the forest, this is the place of the lovers who in both plays escape from reality, and where everything may come true. Therefore the forest corresponds to the world of fantasy. Although in As you like it the fantasy world does not involve magic, the fantasy elements are notably seen. The metamorphosis of Rosalind into a man let her be the ‘fairy’ this time to match every couple with the correspondent one and establish the order as the character of Puck does in A Midsummer Night’s Dream. She plays until the end of the comedy with this changing role of woman and man.’ It is not the fashion to see the lady the epilogue… If I were a woman’ (Epilogue. 2778. 2791). This can only happens in this world, letting the characters dream, Rosalind can dress as a man to teach Orlando how to conquer her love, Orlando can express his love to her through poetry and the exiled ones can sing and play music all day. This time we can define fantasy as those elements which separate us from the harsh reality of the period. The fantasy world this time is seen as the idealized world.

It is to stand out the character of Puck in similarity with Rosalind, both join the couples but they are also the ones who say farewell to the audience. Puck apologizes for the ‘dreams’ lived during the representation of the play; Rosalind says her goodbyes doing a conjuration to the present men and women in order that we love each other.

‘My way is to conjure you, and I’ll begin with

the women. I charge you, O women,

for the love you bear to men, 

to like as much of this play as please you;

and I charge you, O men,

for the love you bear to women as I perceive

 by your simpering, none of you hates them

 that between you and the women

 the play may please’. (Epilogue)

December 11th, 2010

Fantasy and reality in three comedies: A Midsummer Nigt’s Dream, Much Ado About Nothing and As you Like It

Posted by esefer in SECOND PAPER

    

 The use of fantasy  in every Shakespearean play is notably seen in its landscapes, seas, forests, foreign countries and cities to be able to write about anything in these fantastic places. Shakespeare shows a keen interest in a large range of European countries setting his plays in some of them; in France the comedy As you like it, in Italy Much Ado About Nothing and he takes Greece as the scenario in A Midsummer Night’s Dream. The playwright has the power to make these imaginary places real by providing a local address and an identity.

He also associates the characters with places, the most common association as we see in A Midsummer Night’s Dream and As you like it are: those characters who belong to the court and therefore to reality, are found in the cities, and the lovers, the fairies and the exiled ones, far from the city, in the forest, which corresponds to the world of fantasy. This differentiation of scenarios, this double space helps the author to create these two worlds: fantasy and reality, these worlds are opposed, separated from each other and never meeting at any point.

In Shakespeare’s time the vague knowledge of the world and the location of its countries and cities can be observed in his plays. The places represented are never far away from each other, but it works perfectly. For instance in As you like it we move from France to the Forest of Arden in the county town of Warwikshire, England. In Much Ado About Nothing, Shakespeare gives the idea of proximity between Italy and Spain, for instance; the name of Borachio invented by the author being a mixture between Italian and Spanish makes us to notice this, moreover, Don Pedro of Aragon ruled Messina, an Italian city. Maybe Spain and Italy in this period were imagined quite close to each other, not only geographically, but in culture, customs and language as well.

These stereotypes of places and characters are also noticeable in A Midsummer Night’s Dream. Because of some literary works, Greece is known as a country full of mythology, Gods and fairy legends and perhaps that is why he sets magic in this play and  always separates us from England.

All these exotic places outside England such as; Athens, Messina or France, gives fantasy to the plays. Although his geography seems to have very far from documentary, the combination of fantasy and reality works perfectly, because he uses imaginary places, the distant ‘out there’ to tell us familiar situations of the time.

This imaginary geography is due to the lack of geographic knowledge in Shakespearean times; the literary works, the exiles, the wars and negotiations with other countries were the key know about the world.

December 11th, 2010

Introduction

Posted by esefer in SECOND PAPER

‘The De Lessep’s Dance’

Fantasy and reality is seen in every Shakespearean plays. In every play these two worlds are visible in a different way, ones introduce fantasy through supernatural elements, as in A Midsummer Nigth’s Dream,  and others do it in a different way as we will see.

In this paper I will focus on the fantasy and the reality found in three of Shakespeare’s plays, they are the follows; Much Ado About Nothing, A Midsummer Night’s Dream and As You Like It.

As I said before fantasy and reality are not always seen in the same way, that is why firstly, I will analyze those elements of fantasy and reality appear in the three plays together where he uses imaginary places, the distant ‘out there’ to tell us familiar situations of the time and therefore the reality of the period.

Secondly I will analyze Much Ado About Nothing and As You Like It separately and each one in comparison with a Midsummer Night’s Dream already explained in the first paper. For that I will look for another reading of  William Shakespeare’s plays.

Once more we will be able to appreciate Shakespeare’s tremendous ability to create amusing places and situations in his plays.

December 11th, 2010

SECOND PAPER

Posted by esefer in SECOND PAPER

 SECOND PAPER

Subject :# 14159 Curs Monográfic: Shakespeare through Performance Grupo A

Student´s name: Serrano Fernandez, Estefania

Title of the paper: Fantasy vs Reality in A Midsummer Night’s Dream, As you like it and Much Ado About Nothing.

Author or topic: Shakespeare. Midsummer Night’s Dream, As you like it and Much and Ado About Nothing.

Abstract:

Introduction: The focus of this paper is to compare and provide a deep analysis of the two worlds Shakespeare creates in his comedies; A Midsummer Night’s Dream, As you like it and Much and Ado About Nothing, the one of fantasy where everything may come true, against the serious and sober world of reality. Firstly, I will analyze those elements of fantasy and reality in the three plays together where he uses imaginary places, the distant ‘out there’ to tell us familiar situations of the time, and therefore the reality of the period. Secondly I will analyze Much Ado About Nothing and As You Like It separately and each one in comparison with a Midsummer Night’s Dream already explained in the first paper. Conclusion: Once more, Shakespeare believes in this balance between fantasy and reality.

BIBLIOGRAPHY AND WEBLOGRAPHY

 

AUTO EVALUATION: I think that I have done a great paper. Because of the complexity of this one I have dedicated too much time, so  due to this effort and dedication I personally believe that I deserve a 9.

 

   © a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Estefania Serrano Fernandez
esefer@alumni.uv.es

*********************************