Fantasy and reality are prominent themes in every Shakespearean play, but it is seen in each play in a different way. To talk about fantasy and reality in the comedy Much Ado About Nothing we will look for another reading of the play, where this time, I will situate this literary work in the world of reality with fantasy nuances.
As in A midsummer Night’s Dream in Much Ado About Nothing we find fantasy in the lack of conventions in the scenarios created by the author. While the play A Midsummer Night’s Dream could be located in the fantasy world (which also involves magic) with elements, situations which belong to the world of reality, the play Much Ado About Nothing is a more realistic play that on the other hand I will locate in the world of reality with elements, conducts, situations and characters which belong to the fantasy world. We understand by fantasy anything which apart us from the harsh reality of the Shakespearean period.
Perhaps the title Much Ado About Nothing is given by Shakespeare because most of the situations are representative situations of the time. The mixture of fantasy and reality in some of those conventions of the time are the follows:
The main themes of the play are: the importance of honor, a daughter’s duty, the death, the love, the deception, and betrayal, therefore as I said before this play is closer to the reality that to the fantasy world. But as a comedy, all those conflicts the reality represents as in A Midsummer Night’s Dream they have to be solved through the fantasy.
The importance of honor in that era was not, as anything, the same for women and for men and this is reflected in Much Ado About Nothing. Hero’s wedding with Claudio is aborted because she is accused of infidelity; she loses her honor, based upon her virginity, in front of her father by having sexual relations before marriage. In Shakespeare’s times this meant the death of the woman and the lost of her social status. ‘Would the Princes lie, and Claudio lie, Who lou’d her so, that speaking of her foulnesse, Wash’d it with teares? Hence from her, let her die’(4.1.1815-1817) Leonato, after this scandal he orders the death of his daughter. The importance of honor for men differs from the women, being a military question for men. They could defend their honor in a battle, for that reason Beatrice through persuasion, orders Benedict to ‘kill Claudio’ (4.1.1952).
A daughter’s duty in Shakespeare’s period is obedience to her father, In A Midsummer Night’s Dream the duty of Hermia is to marry the man her father Egeus wants for her, in Much Ado About Nothing, Hero’s duty is to obey the decision of her father Leonato as well.
Betrayal and deception are also realistic themes presented in the play. Don John, the villain of the play, lies about the virginity of Hero betraying Claudio. He represents all those malevolence intentions and the deceptions reality carries.
The play shows us multiple endings due to the complex situations, this helps the play to make it more realistic than fantasy, when the audience comes to believe in the illusions of the theatre, and we go back to the world of reality, there is plenty of conflict. But as in every comedy we trust in a happy ending that is why we need to go through fantasy to make it possible.
Above all these themes, what it moves Much Ado About Nothing as the rest of Shakespeare’s plays is the theme of love. Love at first sight and the corresponded love is possible in the theatre and therefore in the world of fantasy. We find a parallelism with the play A Midsummer Night’s Dream in the two couples: Hermia and Lisander are in love from the beginning of the play, so Hero and Claudio. She falls in love with Claudio when he falls for her, but on the other hand Demetrius and Helena as well as Beatrice and Benedict need from fantasy and Helena in love with Demetrius. In contrast with the magic used in A midsummer Night’s Dream to join Helena and Lisander, in Much Ado About Nothing, we will find that fantasy in those scenes where Claudio, Don Pedro and Leonato will act as ‘cupid’ to try to let Benedick know that Breatice loves him and vice versa, Don Pedro says:
‘I will in the interim, undertake one of Hercules labors,
which is, to bring Signior Benedick
and the Lady Beatrice into a mountaine of affection,
th’one with th’other, I would faine have it a match,
and I doubt not but to fashion it,
if you three will but minister such assistance
as I shall give you direction’ (2.1.759-764).
On the other hand Hero and her servant will do the same with Beatrice. At the end, in both plays they have the freedom to choose the day of their weddings even the day after they meet each other. In the following link we can see this funny moment when Benedick first and then Breatrice are persuaded to believe that their love is corresponded, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AlFkbElh44&feature=fvsr. Here we can also notice in the min 7.52 where Benedick is repeating the same words Beatrice pronounces, that Benedick is under his own fantasy he has been conjured by the three cupids and this is the same for Beatrice
In conclusion, we find reality and fantasy in both plays but it is showed in different ways, in both we need to see that balance to have a happy ending, the lovers need to share these two worlds.
on December 12th, 2010 at 19:38
Sorry because of the two audios but is impossible to delete the first one.